grainfedprairieboy grainfedprairieboy:
I feel that I am in an acceptable position to be able to criticise Quebec.
Never said otherwise.
$1:
My wife is a francophone from the province and we travel there often. In fact, she'll be flying out next week for a two week stay. I also own property there and pay taxes on it and have to replace my vandalised Canadian and Alberta flags at my cottage near Port Neuf each summer and one year had to paint a wall after somebody sprayed anti-Canadian graffiti on it.
[Plus the anecdotes]
Sorry to hear that. Definitely won't defend such an attitude - it's stupid and ignorant. But eh, some people, for example, vandalize graveyards, which shows just how moronic people can get.
But really? These things that happened to you were almost certainly not jokes, but genuine ill-intentioned "attacks" and should be considered as such. An insult's an insult, and I won't accept "humor" as an excuse here. Unless you go somewhere and are
expecting that kind of pranks/jokes/"well-intentioned insults" (like at an humorist's show), it's only normal that they draw angry reactions.
camerontech camerontech:
/camerontech cheers on fire_i, not because he wants to defend Quebec, or hates GFPB, or is left-wing, or knows half the conversation. But because he's right and some people on this forum hate to admit it.
*Tips his hat*
'Preciate, good sir.
$1:
What I always find very interesting is when I meet hard core French Quebec nationalists they are always curious what I think of Quebec Separation and I always tell them that people in Alberta generally want them gone. What's unusual is instead of happily agreeing they become defensive and argue why Quebec should remain.
They don't want to hear Quebec isn't vital to Canada. Being dumped would be humiliating - separating under a flurry of "please don't go, you're too important" would be gratifying in a way.
Alberta's case is a bit exceptional since it actually doesn't really need the rest of Canada, even at first glance (it's arguable no province needs the country, but definitely not at first glance), much less provinces that drain it of equalization payments. Therefore it's not so surprising an Albertan wouldn't be bothered by Quebec separation, but if a belief like that spread across the whole of Canada, it would be a hard pill to swallow for someone who wants to believe Quebec is important enough to Canada for the latter to do everything it can to keep it under its control.
Still, despite whatever belief whoever holds, I do think Canada in general would be worse off without Quebec, or any other province for that matter, if only because of imponderables. Chances are Alberta leaving would be, all proportions kept, more damaging than say, Quebec or Nova Scotia, though.