[Scape]

[Thanos]

These are the things JK Rowling actually said, not the things that some "citizen journalists" with their YouTube and Twitter accounts said she said.

In response to the sheer insanity of Scotland deciding to house male criminals in women's jails & prisons simply if they "self-identify" as female:







The "trans" are not under threat. But real biological XX-chromosome women are. This expansion of what "female" means is designed to do one thing only - obliterate the meaning of "woman" altogether. Anyone going along with this is either demented or delusional, and it's amazing how many so-called left-wing progressive males are showing themselves to be as utterly hateful & abusive towards women as their counterparts on the equally vicious fundamentalist right wing are. None of the women, and children, who are going to be attacked and brutally damaged mean a goddamn thing to the ones pushing this. To them all that matters is the victory of their ideology.

Anyone going along with this insanity, especially any of us males, in order to publicly prove their modern urban hipster lefty credentials should be utterly ashamed of themselves. Of all the genuinely stupid & disgusting things that people have ever bought into in the name of virtue-signalling "progress" this gender lunacy could be the absolute worst. It's like dealing with NAMBLA all over again except this time it's as if the pedophiles have the universities, media, and governments on their side.

No dangerous & perverted males in women's spaces and sanctuaries, ever.

[Thanos]

Link between pro-pedophile activists and extremist trans supporters becoming more clear:

https://thepostmillennial.com/pedophili ... ks-rowling

$1:

Perhaps the gravest sin in social media justice circles is believing that men cannot become women. The sin is so great, that a noted advocate of destigmatizing pedophilia wrote an op ed in The Independent slamming a woman for stating that males who commit rapes with their penises are men.

At issue is a recent announcement by police in Scotland that any male who says he is female will be referred as such by both officers and victims of crime, no matter what kind of crime that male commits, including the crime of rape. Courts, too, will require that persons with penises who say they are female will be referred to as female by judge, jury, witnesses, victims, and officers of the court.

JK Rowling is one of these women who is fully and securely sure in her understanding of human biology, and the innate differences between men and women. As such, she doesn't believe that male prisoners should be jailed along side women, or that women who have been raped by males should be forced by police or court of law to refer to those males as women. Rowling believes, as do many, that if a male rapes a woman, there is no conceivable reality in which that male is a woman.

Even if he calls himself a woman, demands to be referred to with female pronouns, wears his hair long, his nails painted, dons dresses and lipstick, Rowling, like many others who have a keen understanding of reality, know that this male is not a woman.

Yet for her trouble in standing up for the rights of female victim of sex crimes, she has been pilloried in the press and by delusional activists who say that males who say they are women are actually and in fact women, even those who commit rape with their male penises.

These critics include NBC contributor and pedophilia apologist Noah Berlatsky who works with Prostasia, who was given a column in The Independent to state his case that Rowling is essentially just mean when she says that rapists should not be given the benefit of their preferred pronouns.

Berlatsky writes that "Rowling — through her tweets, her advocacy and her fiction — seems to imagine a world in which trans women are privileged predators working with a compliant police force to assault innocent cis women. In fact, trans women are a small, marginalized, vulnerable minority, who face terrifying rates of sexual violence from, among others, the police who are supposed to help them."

For Berlatsky, the victim status bestowed upon trans women is of greater importance than any victim status women have. He believes that there should be more sympathy for male-bodied persons who identify as transgender than there should be for women who have a right to single-sex spaces.

Berlatsky is communications director for Prostasia, a pro-pedophile organization that tries to legitimize and destigmatize pedophilia under the guise of helping children. The group offers pedophiles a MAP Support Club, which "is a peer support chat for minor attracted people who are fundamentally against child sexual abuse and committed to never harm children, and is a safe space to have peer support in times of trouble." This group is for people who are aged 13 and up.
After Berlatsky interviewed a professor who wrote a book about destigmatizing pedophilia and was then fired once that work was publicized, he said he was surprised that there had been so much backlash. For Berlatsky, pedophiles and their predilections are already normalized.

His concern is that if victims of sex crimes are not forced to refer to their attackers as women, if that's what the attacker chooses, people who identify as transgender won't report crimes committed against them to police. He has no concern for women who have been sexually assaulted. He has no worry over the difficulty a victim of rape or sexual assault would have in describing her male attacker as female. Bertlatsky seems to think it would be perfectly reasonable to demand that a woman sit on the stand in court saying that the person who raped her with his penis was a she.
The amount of cognitive dissonance and lies that this hypothetical woman would need to tell herself and the court just to find herself in compliance with court rules would be unbearable.

Rowling supports women, women being that human creature that is born with ovaries on the inside of their bodies, that can, barring deformity, carry new life. For her advocacy for women, she has been ridiculed, defamed, threatened, and doxxed. Her talent alone is what has saved her from cancellation, the fact that her creation, Harry Potter and the whole wizarding world, are still such a runaway success has kept her from being pulled from bookshelves and future contracts.

"It’s my belief that if Rowling really wanted to advocate for victims of violence, she would advocate for trans women," Berlatsky writes, "who are disproportionately victims; and if she wanted to advocate for victims of violence, she would want a police force that respects marginalized people, not one that embraces bigotry. 'Please stop causing pain,' one Twitter user begged her after her tweet today. But it seems clear at this point that that is not her main priority."

He's right. Rowling's main priority is to advocate for women, to support women, who are distinctly not men. Rowling is not using her platform to uphold male delusions that dresses, lipstick, and an erection are all that's needed to be female. Instead, she uses her considerable voice, fame, and imagination to take the heat on behalf of women everywhere who are fighting against the colonization of their bodies and the erasure of their autonomy. Berlatsky uses his platform to fight for the rights of pedophiles.

[Scape]

Has she ever considered she could advocate for women without punching down? It's the same argument for the sanctity of marriage types make when they disparage homosexuals. In what way does a gay couple getting married have an impact on your marriage? Rowling is taking cheap shots from a position of privilege. Sad really, kinda expected more from someone who had to work so hard to get where she is.

[Thanos]

I'm not going to talk to you on details if you're not going to address the insanity of things like allowing non-op trans "women" who still have their male genitalia to be put in female-exclusive places like women's prisons. If you don't acknowledge this then you're drunk on the pro-trans social media KoolAid and can't be reached. JK Rowling is a hero. I think so and endless others also think so. If you can't accept that then too bad for you.

I will however use this thread to show the other side, to show how millions and millions and millions of real biological females, straight and lesbian alike, feel & think about what's being done to them for the sake of deranged wokeness. The fight is on and the tide is turning, and I'll do what I can to help the good gals out, and to also vex the sickos.

[Thanos]

Guess this is what being the "kinder, gentler sex" will get women in the end - nothing but lies & gaslighting as the XY keep the XX in their "proper" place:

https://www.denisefindlay.org/post/be-kind

$1:

$1:

“Gaslighting is a form of insidious and covert manipulation where a bully, narcissist, or an abuser targets the victim by making them question their judgements, memory, mind and reality.”

Women are told to be kind, are socialised to be kind. Kindness is a virtue.

$1:

“Be kind whenever possible, it is always possible. Be a kind and loving person, put others first”

Women are being gaslit by an abusive ideology. An ideology that belittles us, denies our voice, enforces their reality in place of our own. And when we refuse to comply, we are traduced as reactionary bigots who should be ashamed.

They ask us to be kind, but the kindness is only one way. They meet our kindness with predatory glee. The patriarchy has reasserted itself in the western world. The uppity women are back in their place subservient to male wants. And if people cannot make themselves fit the ideologically defined gender roles then maybe they need drugs and surgery for the rest of their lives.

Thus, the ideology has twin advantages; re-establish male supremacy and a big payday for the pharmaceuticals and the surgeons.

Public services fly the latest woke rainbow flag. Big business sensing profits climb on board the gender bus. Fashion designers now have their women’s collections modelled by the male bodies they designed for.

So, we are kind while the ideology screws us over. While the people and organisations that should protect us join in. The professional feminists say ‘no debate’. The politicians dismiss our views as ‘not valid’.

And all the while women are kind because if we are not kind then what does that say about us.

So be kind

While they call rapists ‘she’. And put men and condoms into women’s prisons.

While they re-traumatise rape and sexual abuse survivors, by not allowing them female examiners and counsellors.

While they tell women to ‘reframe their trauma’. And a man is appointed CEO of rape crisis.

While they allow men into women’s refuges and support organisations.

While they defund any female-only services that refuse to accept men.


Be kind

While single-sex school toilets are removed and to avoid sharing with boys girls don’t eat or drink all day and self-exclude during menstruation.

While they indoctrinate our children with Queer Theory and invite sexualised drag acts to ‘entertain’ them.

While they ask our children intrusive questions about sex and lifestyle with no care to safeguarding the child or the data.

While they tell children if they don’t conform to their sex stereotype, they were born in the wrong body.

While they tell gay and lesbian children who think they aren’t attractive to their desired sex, they can be 'fixed'.

While they tell girls horrified by porn and the female experience, they can escape all that. They can change sex.

While they sell our children a lie and put them on a lifetime of drugs and surgery.


Be Kind

While males commit 99% of sexual crimes.

While predatory men and men with sexual fetishes gain access to females in their changing rooms, showers and toilets; swimming pools; dormitories; and hospital wards.

While these men provide intimate services to the elderly and disabled.

While these men can join the girl guides and other once female-only organisations.

While women who offer female-only services are pressured to perform these services for men or risk losing their business.


Be kind

While women that speak out are vilified and abused.

While women lose their jobs, their positions and their incomes.

While women are criminalised for telling the truth by a justice system that doesn’t understand the difference between ‘hate’ and self-defence.


Be Kind

While women pay three times over to defend their rights in court, funding both sides. The grassroots organisations defending women and girls; and through taxes our own government and the third sector organisations that intervene against us.


Be Kind

While males dominate female sports and take women and girls’ places and medals.

While men identify into a woman’s place in the boardroom and onto all-women shortlists.

While women’s prizes are given to men and men are included in every women’s category.


Be Kind

While Muslim women and women of orthodox religions have fewer and fewer female-only places and services.

While traumatised women refused to access the services they desperately need due to the presence of men.


Be Kind

While women are dehumanised and we lose the words to describe ourselves and our experiences.

While we become "vagina havers" and "menstruators" and mothers become "birthing persons".

When official statistics erase women so we can no longer quantify female needs or female oppression.


But most of all be kind because men tell you to.

It’s our role as a woman to centre men, to put the wants of men above our and our daughters' needs, every time. We are the second sex. Our safety, dignity and privacy do not matter.

The trans-identifying males do not inherit the titles or the estates or gain access to the male-only clubs.

And the trans-identifying females are never asked to be kind.

[Thanos]

Clearly it was JK Rowling who was wrong & lying & such. One from a couple of years ago, from right here in good ol' hyper-tolerant Canada - trans "woman" in women's shelter boasting on internet about "the thrill" of being admitted into the shelter and then walking around with an erection:

https://www.womenarehuman.com/male-tran ... s-shelter/

$1:

CA — Vancouver, British Columbia. Tyler Porter, a man who identifies as transgender, has publicly boasted on social media of harassing women at the Downtown Eastside Women’s Centre (DEWC) in Vancouver, CA. The Centre’s mission “is to provide a safe, non-judgmental environment for women from all walks of life, who live and/or work in the Downtown Eastside. To achieve this goal, the Centre “provides supportive surroundings with meals, counseling, advocacy and programs which nurture and empower members,” according to their website. They also provide overnight refuge and shelter.

Porter has posted the address of the facility, indicating he was staying there. Additional Facebook posts and images have circulated in which he laughs about subjecting the other women at the shelter to his erect penis and naked body.

Porter has also posted about throwing pills at an older woman in the shelter when she confronted him about his appearance, according to Porter’s Facebook page. “I took out 5 1mg tabs of estradiol and threw them at her one at a time while repeatedly saying ‘no’.”

Good website in general, keeping accurate tabs on on the genuine horror stories being inflicted on natural women and children by the rapist predators using "trans" self-descriptions as camouflage to commit their crimes. Not for the faint of heart or weak of stomach so consider yourself forewarned before you go through the articles.

[Thanos]

But according to the activists and the progressive allies these incidents are so rare that they might as well never have happened at all.

[PluggyRug]

[DrCaleb]

I get so confused. So these people, accused of rape, get put in prison with people of oppositely attributed genitalia. And it's their fault? Not the prisons who assign such things?

[Thanos]

The police and the prison system have their hands tied. They don't make the policy on who gets sent to what jail or lockup. That comes down from the national government, and in all of Britain (especially apparently in Scotland) all the governments implement without question what the trans want. Just like has already been revealed in Canada and in the state prisons in California the trans have been put into women's lockups without much concern at all from officials as to what might happen (and has happened) to natural XX chromosome females when "former" males are put into the female population. It's an arrangement where something awful has to happen and get exposed first, which doesn't happen all that frequently because the media is full on-side with the trans agenda and suppresses these types of stories as much as they can. In the case of the women's rape & domestic abuse shelters they've been threatened with having their funding taken away if they don't admit trans who still have male characteristics, including genitalia.

The solution would be to have a separate facility altogether for trans. But I imagine that, because we're dealing with a runaway ideology determined to trample any dissent into the ground, it would be rejected altogether by the activists and other agents dedicated to imposing this foolishness on an unwilling society. Most people don't understand how cunning sexual predators are, and that if self-identification as trans is all that's required to be admitted into a women-only environment then the pedos & rapists are going to try to fool the system. That the system doesn't appear to be bothering with any sort of checks just increases the likelihood that women in prisons & shelters are basically easy prey for these kinds of perverted criminals.

[rickc]

Thanos Thanos:

The police and the prison system have their hands tied. They don't make the policy on who gets sent to what jail or lockup. That comes down from the national government, and in all of Britain (especially apparently in Scotland) all the governments implement without question what the trans want. Just like has already been revealed in Canada and in the state prisons in California the trans have been put into women's lockups without much concern at all from officials as to what might happen (and has happened) to natural XX chromosome females when "former" males are put into the female population. It's an arrangement where something awful has to happen and get exposed first, which doesn't happen all that frequently because the media is full on-side with the trans agenda and suppresses these types of stories as much as they can. In the case of the women's rape & domestic abuse shelters they've been threatened with having their funding taken away if they don't admit trans who still have male characteristics, including genitalia.

The solution would be to have a separate facility altogether for trans. But I imagine that, because we're dealing with a runaway ideology determined to trample any dissent into the ground, it would be rejected altogether by the activists and other agents dedicated to imposing this foolishness on an unwilling society. Most people don't understand how cunning sexual predators are, and that if self-identification as trans is all that's required to be admitted into a women-only environment then the pedos & rapists are going to try to fool the system. That the system doesn't appear to be bothering with any sort of checks just increases the likelihood that women in prisons & shelters are basically easy prey for these kinds of perverted criminals.

You have been knocking it out of the park in this thread. I would rep if I could. I think that the vast,VAST majority of the people on the planet agree with you. The really tragic part of this story is that people can only say what you are saying by using a pseudonym, like on this site. For anyone to say what you are saying using their real name would be the kiss of death. If they work for a living, they would probably be fired from their job. Good luck ever finding another job. If they owned a business, their business would be canceled. Stores would drop their product line. Media outlets would quit running their adds. Leases would not be renewed.

J.K.Rowling has enough money to never have to work ever again. She never has to write anything ever again, or produce anything ever again. She is free to voice her opinions on anything she chooses. The vast majority of us are not so fortunate. The question is: how did a group of people who make up way WAY less than one percent of the population, get so much power as to completely destroy the lives of anyone who does not kiss their asses and kowtow to every one of their ridiculous demands?

[Zipperfish]

I'm usually a pretty liberal guy, but I am more on JK Rowling's side on this one. Having women referred to as "cis women" or "menstruators" or "people with vulvas" is demeaning. I've lost trans friends over this. It's Orwellian.

[DrCaleb]

Zipperfish Zipperfish:

I'm usually a pretty liberal guy, but I am more on JK Rowling's side on this one. Having women referred to as "cis women" or "menstruators" or "people with vulvas" is demeaning. I've lost trans friends over this. It's Orwellian.

It's ironic too, when Dave Chappelle got in deep trouble for saying that one group should not demean another just because they "don't fit". If they want to be included, they should be inclusive.

[Thanos]

"No one can tell you what exactly JK Rowling did wrong" - Graham Linehan, award-winning writer & comedian, banned from Twitter for "transphobia"