CKA Forums
Login 
canadian forums
bottom
 
 
Canadian Forums

Author Topic Options
Offline
Junior Member
Junior Member
Profile
Posts: 57
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 11:00 am
 


I saw from another post on here that says the british commonwealth would win a war against the united states


That sounds very stupid


The Only one to worry about in England and they would be done soon!

But i know you Canucks think you would beat us

You live in that bubble of ignorance


Offline
Forum Addict
Forum Addict
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 940
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 2:20 pm
 


Watch it. History has shown again and again that a war very, very rarely goes according to how anyone thought it would before hand ie August 1914 "Home by Christmas" they all said.


Offline
Active Member
Active Member
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 230
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 2:46 pm
 


polemarch1 polemarch1:
Watch it. History has shown again and again that a war very, very rarely goes according to how anyone thought it would before hand ie August 1914 "Home by Christmas" they all said.


What are you talking about chief? When the war broke out, not one American ever said that this would be easy or quick! Militarily, YES. But we are not fighting any military. We are fighting insurgents who do not go by the Geneva Convention or conventional warfare. We've been so criticized for a little "hazing" with the prisoner abuse BS, but terrorists can go around killing their own innocent people, and beheadings? What's wrong with this picture? I've criticized my own govt. for not "releasing the hounds of hell!" Our military's hands are tied by the "suits" in Washington D.C. to appease all the "peacenicks" around the world! I've said all along that we need not to worry what the world thinks, and LEVEL Iraq! Send the Mid-East a message! "Fuck with the Bull, you get the horns."


Offline
Junior Member
Junior Member
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 51
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 3:11 pm
 


BigDubUSA BigDubUSA:
polemarch1 polemarch1:
Watch it. History has shown again and again that a war very, very rarely goes according to how anyone thought it would before hand ie August 1914 "Home by Christmas" they all said.


What are you talking about chief? When the war broke out, not one American ever said that this would be easy or quick!


what the hell are you talking about?

if history class from highschool serves correct you guys did not enter the war for a long while after it started.

that is ahard question though, unfortantly, american patriot its a bit hypocritcal to call us ignorant because we'd think the common wealth would win. As i'm allmost positive you "yankees will think you'll beat us because you live in a bubble of iggnorance."


Offline
Junior Member
Junior Member
Profile
Posts: 57
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 3:20 pm
 


Twiz


Look at the plain numbers and the talent....There is no question who would win once the british are gone! Its over we all know it would be over!


Offline
Junior Member
Junior Member
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 51
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 3:33 pm
 


AmericanPatriot AmericanPatriot:
Twiz


Look at the plain numbers and the talent....There is no question who would win once the british are gone! Its over we all know it would be over!
you never know. i'm not saying i dont think america will lose, i'm not sayinmg the commonwealth will lose either.

BUT think about this. basically right now most the countries in the world hate america because of your president. you really think they would come to the aid of america? i honestly, doubt they would.

I hope they don't go to war, as i am from canada, but live in colorado.. so its kinda a lose lose situation, even though i dont like the states, i still live here and would rather not have where i live jeprodized becauser of some petty arguement. i'd also not like to see where i grew up, destroyed.. i still have love for that country.


Offline
CKA Super Elite
CKA Super Elite


GROUP_AVATAR
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 6675
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 3:54 pm
 


It wouldn't be war between the US and the Commonwealth, it would be a war between the US (and whatever allies it could scrape together) and the rest of the world. It would range from huge battles to local insurgencies. The US would be beaten and bloody by the end, with no empire or influence to speak of.

Look at it this way...the US would have no more oil, electricity, or natural gas from Canada. That's immediate and would seriously their ability to produce weapons. The EU would side with Britain. That negates half of Africa and most of South America from helping the US. These are nations that have been complaining of US actions for decades and who have a tradition of interaction with various European countries. They would not back the US in a war that would see the collapse of the American economy.

Oh yeah...the collapse of the American economy. That economy, due to the massive US debt, can be shut down in a couple of days by the Chinese and/or the EU. The Chinese would not side with the US, but may remain neutral (my guess is that they'd peg their money to the Euro, demand payment on the debt owed to them, and the USD would go into freefall; but they'd stay out the military battle. The EU would go with the Commonwealth. So would most of Eastern Europe.

The US would be bankrupt before such a war could even get properly started. That would lead to internal rebellion so they'd be short of troops to go abroad.

To recap...no money for oil to run the tanks and planes, no electricity to make bullets and guns, no toys to placate the masses. The US loses. The American people rise up against their government and demand somebody with a brain.


Offline
Junior Member
Junior Member
Profile
Posts: 57
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 4:03 pm
 


Rev..........you live in a fantasy world



Let China do that we will all die together.....Do you think China wants to save itself or does it want to help the commonwealth no!


It would be a mutual suicide if that happens....So the Chinese would deal with the Third New World Order..........So i dont think China,Or India or Russia would risk there existence for the Commonwealth


Offline
Forum Addict
Forum Addict
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 940
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 4:50 pm
 


BigDubUSA I was responding to Americanpatriots post not commenting on the war in Iraq, which btw I have always and still support. Nor did I say that Americans said the war would be over by Christmas. It was the Europeans

$1:
Look at the plain numbers and the talent....There is no question who would win once the british are gone! Its over we all know it would be over!


Some more examples of wars not going to plan.

Greco-Persian Wars 499 BC-479 BC:
The Persian Empire sends a massive army to crush the city states of Greece. In every engagement the Persians had massive numeracal superiority (though the Greeks fielded better trained military forces) and smart money said they would crush the Greeks. After such battles as Marathon, Platea and Salamis as well as the Spartan king Leonidas stand at Thermopylae the Persians where sent home crying.

March of the 10,000 401 BC
A force of Greek mercenaries accompanies a Persian prince attempting to steal the throne from his brother. After marching from the coast of what is now Turkey to what is now Central Iraq, they met the Persian army. Though they mercenaries where sucessful there employer was killed in the battle (Cunaxa). The Greeks under Xenophon had to march from Central Iraq, north through Kurdistan, along the coast of the Black Sea to Turkey and cross to Greece facing the Persian army and hostile tribes men almost every step of the way. It was thought to be a suicide run, instead the Greeks managed to get home after lot's of marching and hard fighting.

Alexander the Great 336 BC-323 BC
No need to explain this one I think. Who in there right mind would have thought Alexander and his tiny army could have managed to constantly smash the Persian armies and overrun the entire empire? But they did.

Punic Wars 264 BC-241 BC,218 BC-201 BC, 149 BC- 146 BC
The conflicts between Republican Rome and the Carthagian Empire. The first war started over a dispute in Sicily. Rome at the time was a land power and had little experiance in naval warfare well the Carthagians where masters at it. However after initial reversals Rome managed to build a navy and defeat Carthage in an unexpected reversal, imposing humilating terms on Carthage. The 2nd war was fueled by Carthage's desire for revenge. It was thought the Alps couldn't be crossed, but Hannibal did it and surprised Rome inflicting defeat after defeat on the Republic. Rome ended up fighting in Italy, Spain, Macedonia, against Carthage and her allies. Hannibal even threatned to take Rome at one point. It looked as if Rome was done for the count, but she rallied and defeated Carthage's Macedonian allies, killed Hannibals brother and fellow general Hamiclar in battle, conquer Carthages holdings in Spain and mount an offensive at the city of Carthage itself, destroying the Carthagian empire leaving her little more then a city state. About 50 years latter the Romans returned to finish the job and wipe Carthage from the face of the Earth. What was said to have been a simple task took 3 years of hard bloody fighting. The Romans won but it cost them more then they thought.

The Jewish Revolts 66 AD-73 AD, 133-135
In 66 AD Rome was in control of Judea. Well always having problems with the Jews who refused to submit fully to Roman rule, the storm exploded in 66 AD when the Jews rose against the Romans. Well the Roman's where confident of swiftly crushing the Jews due to there soldiers training and better equipment their fanatical adversaries they faced 8 years of fighting. The Jews would again rise under Shimon bar Kochba in 133 giving the Romans another bloody campaign to deal with.

I'll jump ahead a bit now

War of 1812 1812-1815
The United States declares war on Britain and invades her Canadian colonies. Well almost everyone is confident that the Americans will swiftly overrun the colonies every invasion attempt is repulsed, indeed for a while American territory is occupied and Washington DC raided. However the American navy is remarkably succsessful against the supposedly invincable Royal Navy (granted the Brits where distracted by the French). War ends where it starts.

I've already mentioned the First World War. In addition it and the Second World War have way to many examples to list (and I'm getting tired of typing :wink: ) of the battles and what not no occuring or turning out as expected. In addition everyone thought a Jewish state would be wiped out by the Arabs in 1948, it wasn't. In 1967 no one could have predicted in 6 days Israel would wipe the floor with the Egyptian, Jordainian and Syrian armies. There is tons more examples if you look for them.

Many things factor into why a war is won or lost. Training, Numbers and Equipment are factors. So is motivation, terrain and home turf advantage, leadership, weather, Acts of God and other untangibles also refered to as Factor X, politcal will and the will of the people are all factors. There are more. Don't be to quick to declare victory, it could bite you in the ass.


Offline
Forum Addict
Forum Addict
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 940
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 5:02 pm
 


Americanpatriot Rev's description is a plausable outcome of a war between the US and Canada.....though I myself don't place so much trust in the Commonwealth, China, EU, or UN coming to save us, that does not negate the possabilty of an American defeat.


Offline
Active Member
Active Member
Profile
Posts: 299
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 6:26 pm
 


A country like the U.K. or Canada would be orders of magnitude more vulnerable to being virtually shut down by U.S. air and missle strikes and naval interdiction than backward nations like Iraq. Imagine what a Canadian winter would be like when even a limited number of strikes on powerplants, pumping stations and other critical nodes could knock us back to virtually 18th century conditions.

Still, I think the U.S. would lose if it came to a ground invasion of any significant Commonwealth nation.


Offline
Site Admin
Site Admin
 Vancouver Canucks


GROUP_AVATAR
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 9895
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 6:47 pm
 


I always used to think about this when i was a kid, i never wish it would happen, and it never will, but if it did, i imagined something simualr to what rev blair, basically the whole world vs the US.

no one has mentioned Russia? you dont think they'd want a piece of the pie?

And dont forget India is part of the commonealth, there is over a billion people there. http://www.canadaka.net/modules.php?nam ... le&artid=8

And what about all the pissed off middle eastern arab states?


Offline
Forum Junkie
Forum Junkie


GROUP_AVATAR
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 658
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 7:28 pm
 


Rev_Blair hit the nail dead on, the commonwealth would hit the US supply lines, cutting off, food, water, medical supplies, diesel, oils, gas, and thats just for starters.

As in any major conflict there would have to be a build up, any country can see this build up, and start some sort of defensive action.

The US is definatly a major power, but its hard to run a major power (military), when it cant support itself ( fuel ).


Offline
CKA Uber
CKA Uber
 Montreal Canadiens
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 19817
PostPosted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 7:56 pm
 


Gentlemen... Gentlemen... Its not about who would crush who... Afterall we...WE had the greatest regimen ever seen on the face of the earth... The Devils Brigade... And great movie BTW.

Now, since its on the table, In my opinion the closest scenario to happen would be Rev-Blair... And the Commonwealth is made of 54 countries... Including Australia. Soo if the US declares war on the Commonwealth, well, the US won`t stand a chance. The US cannot occupy 54 countries all at once... Plus Iraq, Afghanistan, South Korea, ext, ext, ext. During Sept. 11 they were looking at smashing f-16s into Jetliners........ 8O

And the point of this forum..... :roll:

-M-


Offline
Active Member
Active Member
User avatar
Profile
Posts: 356
PostPosted: Sat Jul 17, 2004 10:19 pm
 


Risk Anyone? :lol:


Post new topic  Reply to topic  [ 35 posts ]  1  2  3  Next



Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest




 
     
All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner.
The comments are property of their posters, all the rest © Canadaka.net. Powered by © phpBB.