Motorcycleboy Motorcycleboy:
xerxes" Dude, I did not write that and you sure as shit know that so don't start putting words in my mouth.
Sorry, I just messed up my quotes. I said that.
$1:
Ah, "left-wing judges", the shibboleth of the right. If you can't see the logic behind the ruling that's too bad. What stereotype are you going to pull out next? They all deserve to be fired because they're all socialists and commies?
Just because those of us on the right point it out, doesn't mean it's a falsehood. Since the Charter was introduced, Canadian judges have been extremely activist, at the expense of parliamentary supremacy.
Do you doubt me? Look up decisions like
Feeny, which saw Justice Sopinka (a civil litigator) re-write 600 years of British common-law and make it almost impossible for police to arrest people in their homes. Or try the
Carter ruling, also known as the "Rich Man's Drunk Driving Defence." This has ensured it is now virtually impossible to get a conviction for drunk driving in this country if the accused has enough money to hire a toxicologist and skilled lawyer. Of course, if you're a brick layer and can't come up with 12 or 14 grand to fight it, you just plead guilty.
Or how about feminist Justice Rosalie Abella, whose acceptance of a bullshit voodoo number formula on so-called "Pay Equity" has cost various levels of governments Billions in payouts. There are others. In Toronto, a transit line that cost millions in preparation costs was halted yesterday when the courts decided the city doesn't have the right to put in transit wherever it chooses. Or the recent ruling by the Supreme Court on Health Care waiting times.
You can agree with these decisions or not, but what you can't dispute is the fact that unelected and unaccountable people are making decisions affecting the very social fabric of this country without oversight by elected, accountable parliamentarians. That's wrong.
Either the courts should stick to interpreting law and not determining social policy, or judges should be elected and accountable for their decisions.