badsector
Active Member
Posts: 235
Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2006 2:47 am
Neither socialism nor capitalism is viable. For short, none of them works. The only system that can function in the long term, provide decent living standards to most of their citizens while also providing opportunities to individuals, is a mixture of both ideas. There needs to be free enterprise but it must not be allowed to run out of control and the government needs to be there to provide necessary services. For that it must collect taxes.<br />
<br />
Capitalism is a one way system. The rich gets richer and the poor gets poorer. After a while, the rich get ultra rich and the poor get destitutes, then the system hits a brick wall and collapses, like it did in the early 20th century (does "Great Depression" ring a bell?). The solution is to maintain a controlled form of capitalism that provides enough protection to the lower classes to preserve a wealthy middle class. Today the middle class is being elliminated, again, and we are going down the same road we did a hundred years ago. It WILL crash, it's guaranteed.<br />
<br />
Having said that, communism the way it was defined by Marx and Engels in the mid 19th century doesn't work either. Marx's ideas were relevant in his time and he tried to find a solution to the problem by designing a perfect society, with equality for all. By now we know that people don't want to be equal. Besides, communism in some places degenerated into military dictatorship and caused lots of human suffering.<br />
<br />
Neither expreme left nor extreme right leads anywhere good. The middle of the road is the way to go.